Book Review: Shadow of Night by Deborah Harkness
If you’re looking for a sequel that deepens an already intricate world while sprinkling in historical detail and a dash of magical intrigue, Shadow of Night by Deborah Harkness will be your new obsession. It’s the second book in the All Souls Trilogy, and let me tell you—this one doesn’t suffer from “middle book syndrome” at all. In fact, it expands on the original in ways that are nothing short of bewitching.
**This post contains affiliate links, and if you purchase anything using these links, I will earn a small commission with no additional costs to you.
The Vibe
At its core, Shadow of Night is a historical fantasy done right. Where the first book (A Discovery of Witches) sets the stage with romance, mystery, and just enough magical tension to make you suspicious of everyone, this sequel plunges you straight into a rich, layered historical setting. The vibe? Imagine you’ve time-travelled to Elizabethan England with a cup of tea in hand, trying to keep up with alchemical experiments and conversations with people like Christopher Marlowe. Yep, it’s that immersive.
“And I am a witch. You promised to accept me as I am—light and dark, woman and witch, my own person as well as your wife.”
World-Building That Delivers
If you are a fan of Harkness’ careful attention to historical detail in book one, prepare for an even richer experience. The novel offers a deep dive into the late 16th century. Deborah Harkness is a historian herself, and her academic expertise is all over the pages (in the best way). You’re not just reading about Elizabethan England—you’re living it. From the smells of London streets to the intricate politics of the time, it’s clear Harkness has done her homework, making you feel like you’ve swapped your 21st-century attire for a ruffled collar and codpiece.
While the book maintains historical accuracy, it doesn’t drown out the magic. The blend of sorcery, alchemy, and history provides a uniquely textured experience. Immersed in the book, I felt I could make magic, just as Diana did.
Characters You Want to Follow Through Time
Diana Bishop, historian and witch, is still grappling with her magical identity, and her journey in Shadow of Night is just as much about personal growth as it is about mastering her powers. She’s smart, resourceful, and—thankfully—not the type to wait around for anyone to save her. It’s a type of woman I can refer to. I enjoyed knowing her character and her devotion to her loved one. We dream about that kind of powerful bond between lovers.
Matthew Clairmont, the centuries-old vampire, follows her on her journey of discovering who she is and who she is meant to be. Vampires in fiction have a long history of being overly brooding or annoyingly perfect, but Matthew strikes a solid balance. His character deepens in this book, and you see more of his past—complete with all its emotional baggage. The chemistry between Diana and Matthew remains palpable but never overshadows the plot.
One thing that Deborah Harkness does particularly well is ensure that her supporting cast is anything but flat. From the School of Night members like the enigmatic Kit Marlowe to Diana’s magical family, each character adds a new layer to the colourful palette.
Themes That Stick With You
One of the most compelling aspects of Shadow of Night is its exploration of identity, power, and legacy. Diana’s struggle with her magic is a broader metaphor for self-acceptance, while Matthew’s battle with his past touches on themes of redemption and guilt. The time-travel aspect isn’t just a fun plot device; it makes you think about how history shapes identity and how much of our personal growth is tied to confronting the past. How much burden do we carry from our past lives? This makes me reflect on life in general. Is this the only reality surrounding us, or are there more of them in other dimensions?
The Pacing: A Slow Burn Worth Savoring
If you like a quick, fast-paced read, this might feel like a slow burn. But Shadow of Night delivers for fans who appreciate detailed, intricate storytelling. The book is dense with historical references, magical lore, and character development. While it’s not action-packed in every chapter, the richness of the world more than makes up for it. Once I started, I stayed up many nights too late because it was the only time I could read, but it was hard to put down my Kindle and leave the fantasy world that seemed like reality.
Why It’s Worth Your Time
If you enjoy historical fantasy, Deborah Harkness is the right choice for you. Shadow of Night is for readers who love to be immersed in a world that’s as intellectual as it is magical. Whether you’re a fan of history, fantasy, or powerful character-driven stories, this book has something to offer.
I hope I have made enough magic to entice you to read this magical story. I can’t emphasize enough how perfectly Shadow of Night sets up the final book in the trilogy. It’s not just a bridge; it’s a full-fledged adventure that stands on its own.
You’re in for a treat if you haven’t started the All Souls Trilogy yet. But if you’re already on board, buckle up because Shadow of Night will take you on one unforgettable journey.
Myvirtualcupoftea.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. This post might also contain affiliate links to other sites. And if you purchase anything using these links, I earn a little commission with no extra costs for you. Thank you for supporting my blog!
My Virtual Cup of Tea 
3 thoughts on “Shadow of Night by Deborah Harkness: A Spellbinding Sequel – No Spoilers!”